Stormy in the North TOTP question

Albums, singles, songs and general Wildhearts banter

Stormy in the North TOTP question

Postby Jimmy79 » 29th Dec 09, 20:05

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-dpecFHle10

is it just me or is there a 5th singer on this?
I can hear Cj and Ginger lower than this odd third voice
and it aint Stidi cause he aint singing at the same points
the same goes for danny

or....am I indeed talking huge donkey balls? :o
Image
Jimmy79
 
Posts: 200
Joined: 15th Oct 06, 22:53

Postby Col » 29th Dec 09, 20:14

eeeee oooooorrrr.

Back in the old days the bands used to record the song earlier in the day"live" and mime to it on the nite. Or just mime full stop.

Although it sounds live I'm not sure it is as Ginger isn't asking for more monitor or anything :D
User avatar
Col
 
Posts: 2106
Joined: 12th Feb 06, 16:28

Postby Jimmy79 » 29th Dec 09, 20:22

nah I dont think they mimed later
bands either mimed to there studio version or did it live ( or just sung live )
it was stopped being live on TV due to Nirvana's lyric change on teen spirit that time
and some others to I'm sure

but that doesnt sound like Ginger at all
more like willie to be honest!
Image
Jimmy79
 
Posts: 200
Joined: 15th Oct 06, 22:53

Postby Col » 29th Dec 09, 20:33

or a mix of live and backing:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eo8Druxw9wg :D
User avatar
Col
 
Posts: 2106
Joined: 12th Feb 06, 16:28

Stormy in the North TOTP question

Postby Ginger » 29th Dec 09, 21:13

The performance was 100% live.
Sometimes the transition from recording a song to playing it live goes through a few different characters before you get to a comfortable place with the song.

Gx
Ginger
 
Posts: 96
Joined: 9th Feb 06, 16:54

Postby Col » 29th Dec 09, 21:23

There we go, straight from the top :D
User avatar
Col
 
Posts: 2106
Joined: 12th Feb 06, 16:28

Postby mochy » 30th Dec 09, 01:53

I remember CJ singing in a kind of falsetto voice on this performance, different from the record - maybe that's what you're hearing?
mochy
 
Posts: 47
Joined: 1st May 06, 15:01

Re: Stormy in the North TOTP question

Postby Cov Danny » 15th Jan 10, 12:22

I remember being overly excited when it appeared at the end match of the day ... some dreary cup tie i think involving West Ham ... What an amazing tune !!
Cov Danny
 
Posts: 6
Joined: 11th Jan 10, 17:37


Return to Wildhearts Music and General Chat

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests